Voodoo – circa 70s

Band Voodoo at Hotel Metropole

– L to R: Maneck Bharucha, Farhad Behrana, Farhad Mistri, Rayomand Masters (RIP) and Savi Tengra. (Photograph courtesy Michael Ali)

 “Voodoo” playing at The Discotheque, Hotel Metropole (circa 1972)

L to R: Rayomand Masters (late, RIP), Maneck Bharucha, Farhad Mistri, Farhad Behrana and Savi (Sam) Tengra. (Photograph courtesy Farhad Keki Behrana‎)




Mansoor Fatah as the Craziest Musician

Those who have watched the Fatah Brothers perform live in their dhotis, barefoot and bare chested in Karachi know that I’m right when I say that they were an extraordinary breed of musicians.

This is Mansoor Fatah as the Craziest Musician.  He did a one man band stint all over Europe with a huge fan base..

People used to say that from outside the hall it sounded like a full band was performing till they finally walked in… Check this out!


Mansoor Fatah as the Craziest Musician


Bang Bang with Malcolm Goveas


© Legendary Musicians of Karachi

An unpretentious human being who is ever so eager to make you laugh with his infectious sense of humour but when he’s behind that drum set…. he transforms into this relentless beast!

He coyly says that he simply makes all the noise in the background but he knows it’s much more than just ‘noise’.

It has been said that drummers are the backbone of a band and Malcolm has always been one outstanding backbone even way back when he was with the Communication.

It took a while to get hold of Malcolm but I am truly thankful to him for doing this interview with us.

Let’s hear more from him.

ldg ~ Your band of the 70sCommunication without doubt was in a league of its own. ‘Communication’ was one of my ‘most’ favourite bands of the 70s. Not that I got to see you perform live but from the tracks that we’ve heard on LMK, the superiority of the musicians is pretty evident.  Tell us how it all started and what drove you guys to produce such high-quality music/sound?

Malcolm ~ We had the effortless Edgar Saville on keys, the versatile Vandy (Alan Vanderlowen), the rave bass player Alan Dias, the hard working and talented Errol D’silva on lead and ‘Saxy’ Franky on sax.  I just made a lot of noise at the back.

We chose to rehearse and play songs from Crosby Stills and Nash, Little Feat, Steely Dan, while also doing other popular songs of the time. This perhaps kept it fresh.  We did ‘Credence Clear Water’ and ‘King Crimson’,

I give Alan Vanderlowen much credit for introducing us to a wide selection of music, from Bob Marley to Jethro Tull, King Crimson to Little Feat and many others.

Click on Communication live  to listen to some of their old recordings or the youtube video above.


Malcolm with the Communication

ldg ~ Malcolm when did you start playing the drums and what led you to it?

Malcolm ~ My first bass drum was the wooden crate that housed the fridge that my dad bought from overseas.  That bass drum worked a little differently.  I had to bang my heel real hard on the crate to get a bass sound (ouch!) and a stainless thali! was my snare.  That’s how simple it was and the best sound ever (at least to me).

I was in Year 6 when I joined the ‘St Patrick’s School Band’ (marching band) as a drummer and played alongside Lawrence Andrade and Godfrey Mendes.

Back then we used to march down the streets of Saddar playing for processions, sports day events etc.  I vividly remember enjoying the Channa Puri from Joseph’s canteen at St. Pats that Monty (our band master) would treat us after performing.

I used to live at FCCHS opposite Edgar Saville’s apartment on the ground floor.  In those days the ‘In Crowd’ was considered the best live band in Karachi.  The In Crowd would practice at Edgar’s apartment and we kids would climb on the windows to try and get a peak at them (they would not let us in and rightly so!).

Edgar, Ivan, Sydney and can’t remember the bassist at the time.  Perhaps it was Noel and they jammed some mean tunes.  The sound of the snare drum just killed me…  I was so inspired and knew it was time that I got hold of a drum set.  My “Stainless Thali” would not cut it anymore.  After a few weeks of relentlessly bugging my parents, off we went to ‘Saeed Music Palace’ and came back with my first drum kit.  Bright shinny tinsel blue, all with shiny silver looking cymbals and rims and camel skins, little did I know that camel skins don’t work in the winter LOL!  We had to light bulbs to heat the skins to get any sound from them in the colder months.

Excitement soon turned to frustration!  Those shinny silver looking cymbals never did sound anywhere close to the sound coming out from Edgars house!

A bit of a deviation from the question but I remember playing on a Pakistani drum set with Errol, Alan, Cookie and Busheen at someone’s house in Defence and we called ourselves the ‘HAMMER HEADS’ …. Yeah

Anyway, my first kit was just a starter kit and I started bugging my parents again.  My dad was working on a ship that regularly docked in Singapore.  At first he said No, and that I should concentrate on my education but I was persistent and kept bugging him till he finally gave in.  Two months later he returned with a Red and Black Pearl kit with Zildgian cymbals. I was over ecstatic.

A big shout out to Pawan Rawat from India for sharing these videos with LMK!

ldg ~ Who inspired you at the time?

 Malcolm ~ Thaddeus Pinto was by far the best drummer and his playing technique really inspired me.

ldg ~  Your favourite ‘live’ band/bands of Karachi?

Malcolm ~ The Talismen and Incrowd were really good bands.  If I am not mistaken both Talismen and Incrowd played at the CYC hall for a jam session.  Solid sound.  Still remember Norman singing ‘Child in Time’ and ‘Evil Ways’ and so many others.  The In Crowd also played a very well.

But as far as innovation goes, my vote goes to “Hello Why are You”, with Mansoor Fatah, Farooq Fatah and Atiq Rehman performing songs from Zepplin (Ocean, Rock and Roll), Stevie Wonder.  They were way ahead of their time.  Super intense sound.

They also wrote a song called “Freedom” and were on National TV.  Great rock song but Pakistan was not ready for them.  I remember filling in for Atiq for one day at the Horseshoe Restaurant.  I felt like a total misfit.

Coming back to my Red and Black Pearl drum set.  Hey whoever’s got that drum set it is now worth at least $100,000.  It had been through two “water world” scenarios and has a lot of history.

Once the Jamiat guys after firing on us at a Karachi University show, threw it in the pool (of course we all ran for our lives before it got that bad) and the other time is was submerged in water was when I played for Underground 4 at the Horseshoe Restaurant.

God bless “Brave Heart” Mansoor Fatah for diving into the water, tying the rope to the drum set and then swimming back up to help us pull the set up. He did that for all our equipment. Thank you Mansoor!

Did you know that Mansoor performed bare-chested and wore a “dothi” at many concerts.  Wow! How incredibly bold.  He could have easily passed off as a hippie in Goa.  LOL.  Farooq was always experimenting with sounds for example putting a speaker on a ” mudca” and playing bass through it.

Live performances of Malcolm Goveas with Junoon.  Video courtesy Pawan Rawat

ldg ~ Concerts you played that brought the best in your music? Or your most memorable experience as a musician.

Malcolm ~ I remember we (Junoon) played in New Delhi for the MTV awards and our Tabla Player Ashiq Ali was practicing in the camp (tent) before the show and the Def Leppard drummer came in to see us.  He was blown away with the intricate rhythm Ashiq was playing.

Right after we played ‘Sting’ came on stage and we got to meet him.

I have played with many singers and performers but Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, was one singer that simply blew me away.  It was an honour to perform with him.  The power in his voice, vocal range was so incredibly alluring.  I played with Nusrat on 4 occasions ~ ‘Dum Must’ rendition.

I remember playing at ‘the Luvin’ at Hotel de France near the Karachi airport, and our then lead guitarist Huma Azad was leaving for Jeddah.  I went to Iggy Fernandes’ house and asked him if he would like to audition for Tears Silence and Laughter (Glen Boyle, Bobby and David Fredrick aka Daoud Rafik, myself and Huma Azad).  So Iggy went with me and blew us all away playing songs from Santana and Deep Purple etc.  Huma was speechless.  Iggy joined the band.  One exceptional guitar player! Amir Zaki is another in that league. I played with Amir Zaki for two concerts before Junnoon.

Other than that I’ve enjoyed performing live in Dubai, Maritius, Central Park and a few others.

Video courtesy Pawan Rawat

ldg ~ What styles of music do you prefer?

Malcolm ~ Classic and slow rock. However, when we did covers, I never wanted to play it exactly the same way…  nice excuse 🙂   I always wanted to add my own two cents.

ldg ~ Something you really try and try with the drums and could not get yet or are not satisfied with the results?

Malcolm ~ I   could never play double bass.  My son Sheldon Goveas can play double bass with ease. (Damn how the hell does he do it!) There are many things I cannot do yet…… you always keep learning.

ldg ~ Favourite drummers?

Malcolm ~ Right now Avery Molek is my favourite drummer.  Check him out!

When you see 7 and 8 year old drummers play like that, trust me I don’t want to do any interviews LOL.

Back in the day, Ian Paice (Deep Purple) was my favourite drummer.  His rock style, intricate rolls, technique, fluency just blew me away and he is still playing.

Billy Cobham ~ I was fortunate to see him perform live in New York at a small club when Paulina and I went on our honeymoon many moons ago.  Great inspiration and terrific performance. Jazz rock and rock.

Neil Peart from Rush.  Smooth and intricate timing. complex rolls.

Current drummers, just so many.  One is Mike Mangini

‘Music is All I know’ with Hilary Furtado

Hilary Furtado

© Legendary Musicians of Karachi

If you are in the music industry in Pakistan then you will certainly have encountered Anthony Hilary Furtado aka ‘Hilary’ at some point in time.

If you haven’t, then indeed you haven’t been around much because this man is everywhere, from live entertainment to main stream music; he has done and seen it all!

He has played with some of the best musicians in Pakistan and probably all the hotels in town.  This man goes a long way and still continues his regular contract at the Pearl Continental.

 He recently performed with the Ari Roland Jazz Quartet at the American consulate and was awarded a Certificate of Appreciation.

Our LMK contributor, Chester Williams recently cornered him for this interview.

 contd. below

Chester Williams interviewing Hilary Furtado

Chester Williams interviewing Hilary Furtado

Hilary how and when did it all begin for you?

 I started playing in 1968.  First I taught myself how to play the guitar and whilst playing for a Thai band in Singapore in 75/76 I picked up the saxophone; again self taught.  Along with both these instruments I took up vocals as well.

 Do you come from a musical family?

No! – nobody in our family was musical.  Somehow it just hit me and my brother,  Nobby Furtado, who btw. is a fantastic bass player.

Which famous musicians have you learnt from or were inspired by?
Tell us about your experiences.

Being in the music field, I have admired most musicians of the yester years but most drawn towards instrumental and sentimental stuff..

My favorites are here in Pakistan with whom I have had the opportunity to perform with i.e. Alamgir, Mohammed Ali Sheikhi, Sadaf Munir, Tehseen Jawed, Faqir & Junoon…  I like Ali Zafar but haven’t performed with him yet.

What are your fondest musical memories?

I have always had good memories here in Pakistan and even abroad in countries like UK, Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand & UAE.

contd. below

Chester (L) and Hilary Furtado (R)

Have you recorded any of your music?

I have recorded with various singers and musicians and for those who don’t know I also do loads of jingles aired on the local channels.


Do you have some original music that you would like to record through the support of LMK?

Yes, in the near future.

Tell us about errors that occur at live performances.  Have you encountered any and how do you handle them?

With all the experience up my sleeves I manage to cover up mistakes.  With live music you just go with the flow and enjoy the experience. 


Do you get nervous before any performance?

No, not really but yes I do remember an instance in the mid 70’s when I went to Singapore and had to audition with the guitar.  I was dreadfully nervous but eventually got through.  I have been in the music business for so long now that nervousness is a thing of the past.



Do you still practice and how often?

Yes, I practice every day for an hour or two


I hear that you used to teach music.  Tell us about it?

I used to give vocal lessons to the kids at the Beacon House but not at present.


Are you still performing ‘live’?

I’m performing with  “The Keynotes”!  Yes! We are still keeping the name going.  We perform at the Marco polo in Pearl Continental and twice a week at the Sind Club.  Also had the pleasure of performing live at the French & Russian Consulates.

How do you balance your busy music schedule with other obligations – family/job?

Thank God I have never had a problem!  Made sure I took time out to spend with my family and I am thankful to them for always supporting me and my music.

What words of advice do you have for the young musicians of Karachi?

My advice to all young musicians is that music is like the ocean, a very vast field thus don’t jump ahead too fast!!  Take it one day at a time, enjoy the experience and you will flourish.

Interviewed by ~ Chester Williams
Artwork ~ by ldg 

With Robin John there is no end ~ by ZeeJay

Robin John

© Legendary Musicians of Karachi

Like many upcoming musicians of his time, my father started his music career in a popular band called “The End of the Road”.

The band consisted of three musicians who are no short of introduction; Mario Rebello (drums), Terrence Simpson (bass), and Patrick Callaghan – R.I.P (rhythm).

~ contd. below

Mario Rebello (drums), Terrence Simpson (bass), Patrick Callaghan – R.I.P (rhythm)
and Robin John (keys)
Artwork ~ by ldg © Legendary Musicians of Karachi

It was in 1976 when the band recruited a 19 year old organist, who had no prior professional experience what-so-ever; All he brought with him was 6 years of dedicated practice, his skill with a church organ and his overwhelming love for music.  Robin John was introduced as the official organist for “The End of the Road”.

“The End of the Road” came to an end for Robin John in 1979 when he decided to move on and further pursue his career in music.  He switched to recordings and worked as an independent keyboard player and a music arranger in the Pakistan Film Industry.

At age 21 Robin John (as we say in NY) was “running the town”! He was working with top vocalists like Alamgir and Muhammad Ali Shehki as a back-up musician and top-notch composers like Karim Shahabuddin, Sohail Rana and Nisar Bazmi.

~ contd. below

Pakistan Day Parade 1989 New York
Mr. Robin John accompanied Mr.Sohail Rana & Team

Robin John represented Pakistan internationally and was the first Christian musician to be awarded the Presidential Award by the former president of Pakistan, Gen. Pervaiz Musharraf in the year 2000.

Now, for the past nine years he has been living in the US and there is still no end to his musical journey.  He is producing music in the US and is currently working with celebrated Indian vocalists.

And there’s still more to come, because when you’re talking about Robin John, there is no END!

By ZeeJay

~ contd. below

‘With Robin John there is no end! ‘ ~ by ZeeJay

*Note by ldg ~  Robin John is the son of the legendary singer S. B. John who was awarded the ‘Pride of Performance’ award by the President of Pakistan, Asif Ali Zardari on August 14, 2010.


Special Thanks to Glen Boyle ~ by Darryl Leachay

Glen Boyle
Artwork ~ by ldg © Legendary Musicians of Karachi

© Legendary Musicians of Karachi

Photograph contributed by Sabby Patrick

I grew up playing bass during the post martial law era, so did not get to hear some of these legendary musicians, but do recall GLEN BOYLE of the ‘Blackjacks’ as one of the most encouraging musician for young up coming musicians.

As an up coming musician at the time, I recall visiting Kewal and Glen would let me play a couple of songs on stage.   He also gave me my first guitar.

Later on, when I started playing for the VISIONS, He encouraged my band by letting us share the stage with his band the BLACK JACK’S.

Full props to Glen Boyle!!

Communications ’70s – Dedicated to Alan Vanderlowen ~ by Eric Dsilva

Alan Vanderlowen of the Communications singing ‘Can’t Hold Out’

Communications with Legendary Musicians

Edgar Saville ~ keyboards

Frank Anthony ~ vocals and percussions

Alan Dias ~ vocals and bass

Errol (Eric) Dsilva ~ vocals, lead and rhythm guitar

Malcolm Goveas ~ drums

Alan Vanderlowen ~ vocals, lead and rhythm guitar

Recorded in the 70s